11
Feb
2020

Share

Downgrades galore as we head into interim reporting season

With many Australian companies sitting on lofty valuations, woe betide those that disappoint the market. Because, as we have already seen, investors have taken a big stick to companies that cut their earnings outlook.

In the lead-up to the interim results reporting season, the range of trading updates tends to be skewed to the downside, and this period has been no exception, with 26 companies releasing downgrades to guidance since the end of December by our count as compared to 7 upgrades. As of today, we can add Boral and probably Blackmores to the list.

What has been noticeable has been the aggressiveness of the market’s reaction to the announcements, both on the day and since. The charts below show both the absolute share price movement on the day of the announcement (or the following day if the announcement was released after the market close) as well as the change relative to the movement in the ASX 300 index for companies releasing negative trading updates since the start of December.

Figure 1: Change in share price on the day of the announcement

Screen Shot 2020-02-11 at 9.21.24 am

Source: Bloomberg, MIM

The average performance on the day was -12 per cent. However, these stocks tended to continue to underperform the market after the first day, with average underperformance relative to the broader market since the first of trading post the announcement of -6 per cent.

Figure 2: Change in share price from the first trading day following the announcement to today

Screen Shot 2020-02-11 at 9.21.58 am

Source: Bloomberg, MIM

The change in the share price following the trading update reflects the combination of the change in the expected near-term level of earnings, as well as any changes to the market’s perception of the value of those earnings and future growth. For most of the stocks releasing negative trading updates, the impact of lower near-term earnings expectations on their share price was compounded by a reduction in the market’s perceived value of those earnings.

This is shown in the following chart, which shows the percentage change in the company’s PE ratio pre and post the release of the trading update. On average, the stocks downgrading guidance in December and January have suffered a 9 per cent reduction in their PE ratio based on the financial year following the current year.

Figure 3: Percentage change in PE ratio based on average sell side analyst forecast before and after trading update – current and next forecast financial year

Screen Shot 2020-02-11 at 9.22.28 am

Source: Bloomberg, MIM

With the market PE having increased materially over the last year on the back of falling discount rates, the price/value attributed to each unit of earnings growth has increased materially. The consequence of this is an increase in companies that disappoint against market expectations. This adds to the risk outlook over the coming reporting season, with surprises likely to result in larger moves in share prices than we have seen previously.

Figure 4: ASX 200 Industrials ex Financials

Screen Shot 2020-02-11 at 9.23.12 am

Source: Morgan Stanley

Our Funds

The Montgomery Fund

  • AUSTRALIA/NZ
  • Concentrated high conviction equities
  • From $25,000
Learn More

Montgomery Global Fund

  • GLOBAL
  • Concentrated high conviction equities
  • From $25,000
Learn More

Montaka Global Access Fund

  • GLOBAL
  • Access long/short global equity portfolio
  • From $50,000
Learn More

Montgomery Global Equities Fund (ASX:MOGL)

  • GLOBAL
  • Concentrated high conviction equities
  • No minimum investment - see your broker limits
Learn More

Montgomery Small Companies Fund

  • AUSTRALIA/NZ
  • Concentrated high conviction equities
  • From $25,000
Learn More
Close

Our Funds

Concentrated High Conviction Equities

Listed

Montgomery Global Equities Fund (ASX:MOGL)

Global
Available on the ASX as an Exchange Traded Managed Fund, invests in 15 to 30 quality global businesses for long-term capital growth with a target distribution yield of 4.5% per annum. Mirrors the strategy of the Montgomery Global Fund.
Unlisted From $25,000

Montgomery Global Fund

Global
Invests in 15 to 30 quality global businesses for long-term capital growth. Priced daily. Mirrors the strategy of the Montgomery Global Equities Fund (ASX:MOGL).
Unlisted from $25,000

The Montgomery Fund

Australia/NZ
Aims to provide long-term growth and income by investing in 20 to 40 high-quality Australian and New Zealand businesses trading at attractive valuations. Priced daily.
UNLISTED FROM $25,000

Montgomery Small Companies Fund

Australia/NZ
Aims to provide long-term growth by investing in 30 to 50 high quality, undervalued, Australian and NZ small and emerging companies with strong growth potential. Priced daily.
Unlisted from $1 Million

The Montgomery [Private] Fund

Australia/NZ
Seeks to deliver absolute returns from a portfolio of high-quality Australian and New Zealand businesses. Capital preservation is paramount. By invitation only.

Alternate Equity Strategies

New Fund

Montaka Global Extension Fund (ASX: MKAX)

GLOBAL
An ASX-quoted managed fund, typically, the Fund seeks to hold 15 to 30 long positions and partially offsets these with 10 to 40 short positions, operating with 130% exposure to its long portfolio and 30% exposure to its short portfolio, resulting in a net market exposure of around 100%. Features a target distribution yield of 5% per annum.
Unlisted from $50,000

Montaka Global Access Fund

Global
Aims to generate materially higher risk-adjusted returns, net of fees, than is generally available in the equities market over the medium term. Priced monthly. Provides retail investors access to the Montaka Global Fund.
Unlisted from $1million

Montaka Global 130/30 Fund

Global
Provides the opportunity to benefit from both the gains of extraordinary businesses and the declines of deteriorating businesses through a global equity active extension strategy, which has the potential to significantly outperform the broader equities market over time. Seeks to generate double-digit annual average returns, net of fees. Daily priced.
Unlisted From $1 Million

Montaka Global Fund

Global
Aims to generate materially higher risk-adjusted returns, net of fees, than is generally available in the equities market over the medium term. By invitation only.